Synonyms for Dismay (same or very similar meaning)
WordNet sense 1 (the feeling of despair in the face of obstacles):
discouragement, disheartenment
WordNet sense 2 (fear resulting from the awareness of danger):
alarm, consternation
WordNet sense 3 (fill with apprehension or alarm; cause to be unpleasantly surprised):
appal, appall, horrify
WordNet sense 4 (lower someone's spirits; make downhearted):
deject, demoralize, depress, dispirit, demoralise, get down, cast down
From the ODE community, based on WordNet
add/edit