Synonyms for Indifferent (same or very similar meaning)
WordNet sense 1 (having only a limited ability to react chemically; chemically inactive):
inert, neutral
WordNet sense 2 (not reacting chemically):
unreactive
WordNet sense 3 (characterized by a lack of partiality):
unbiased, unbiassed
WordNet sense 4 (showing lack of favoritism):
impartial
WordNet sense 5 (being neither good nor bad):
so-so
WordNet sense 6 (marked by a lack of interest):
apathetic
WordNet sense 7 ((often followed by `to') lacking importance; not mattering one way or the other):
immaterial
WordNet sense 8 ((usually followed by `to') unwilling or refusing to pay heed):
deaf
WordNet sense 9 (marked by or paying little heed or attention):
heedless, unheeding
WordNet sense 10 (lacking in interest or care or feeling):
unconcerned
From the ODE community, based on WordNet
add/edit