Synonyms for Unsympathetic (same or very similar meaning)
WordNet sense 1 ((of characters in literature or drama) tending to evoke antipathetic feelings):
unappealing, unlikable, unlikeable
WordNet sense 2 (not having an open mind):
closed
WordNet sense 3 (not receptive):
unreceptive
WordNet sense 4 (lacking in sympathy and kindness):
unkindly
WordNet sense 5 (lacking kindness):
unkind
WordNet sense 6 (not agreeing with your tastes or expectations):
disagreeable
WordNet sense 7 (not suitable to your tastes or needs):
uncongenial
From the ODE community, based on WordNet
add/edit